#FactCheck: Old EVM Protest Video Misleadingly Shared as Demonstration Against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar

Introduction

For years, the story of terror recruitment in Jammu & Kashmir followed a familiar arc: physical infiltration across the Line of Control, local Over Ground Workers (OGWs) acting as couriers, and recruitment pitches on mainstream apps like WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger. Indian security agencies built entire surveillance architectures around that arc. Now, officials say, the architecture is being outflanked in a way few anticipated: through pornography and dating platforms.

The New Front: Chat Rooms Nobody Is Watching

According to officials cited in recent reporting, Pakistan-based terror handlers working in coordination with Pakistan's ISI have begun exploiting the real-time chat features built into pornography and dating websites to reach recruits in Jammu & Kashmir. These pornography platforms feature real-time chat tools that operate under the guise of helping users find dates nearby, and handlers are exploiting that feature to broadcast messages and coordinate activities. It's a strikingly mundane pivot for an organisation engaged in violent extremism, but that is precisely the point that nobody expects a counter-terror dragnet to be watching a dating chatbox.

Officials say the tactic is designed to evade the surveillance that has become standard on conventional social media platforms, allowing handlers to convey instructions to recruits while staying off the radar of established monitoring tools. WhatsApp, Signal and Facebook Messenger have all, in various ways, become known quantities to Indian intelligence subject to legal intercepts, metadata analysis and years of institutional familiarity. A chat window buried inside an adult content site is not.

Tor, Encrypted Nodes, and Apps Built to Disappear

Other than porn sites, investigators have also flagged a cluster of niche, privacy-first messaging apps that route traffic through Tor-based, encrypted nodes to mask user identity. Security agencies have placed a wide array of specialised digital tools under scrutiny, with terror handlers relying on Tor-based messaging applications like Coatex and Conion to route data through encrypted nodes and obscure user identities. Access to at least one of these apps' installation files is reportedly already restricted within India, though enforcement against sideloaded Android packages remains an uphill battle.

What makes these platforms attractive to handlers isn't unique code so much as the design philosophy behind privacy-first messaging generally. Some of these apps offer only basic encryption, while others go further with end-to-end encryption, self-destructing messages, and strong on-device encryption algorithms that keep data processing off any third-party server. Several reportedly allow account creation without a phone number or SIM verification, stripping away one of the most basic identity anchors that Indian telecom-linked surveillance depends on.

There's also an operational, almost logistical, reason for the shift: connectivity. Officials note that some of these applications provide end-to-end encryption, self-destructing messages and registration without a phone number or email, making it difficult for security agencies to trace users, even as terror networks also shift away from commonly used platforms. In the hilly, forested and often poorly connected terrain of Jammu's border districts, apps engineered to function on weak 2G or EDGE networks have an obvious tactical advantage over data-hungry mainstream platforms.

VPNs, Banned Apps, and a Cat-and-Mouse Game

Virtual Private Networks add another layer of obfuscation, letting operatives access apps banned in India and mask the geographic origin of their traffic. This isn't new tradecraft, but its pairing with adult-content chat infrastructure and Tor-routed messaging represents a genuinely novel combination in the Kashmir context, according to the officials describing the pattern to reporters.

The broader trend line, officials say, is a steady migration away from platforms Indian agencies have learned to monitor. Terror networks are increasingly moving away from mainstream, commonly used platforms in favour of more obscure alternatives, forcing intelligence agencies into a perpetual game of catch-up: each time a monitoring capability matures against one platform, handlers migrate to the next.

This is not the first time investigators have flagged this cat-and-mouse dynamic. Reporting on a recent case in Jammu's Bathindi area described a 19-year-old allegedly radicalised through the encrypted app. Session the same platform reportedly linked to suspects in a Delhi bomb plot investigation after months of contact with Pakistan-based handlers. Investigators in that case noted that terror organisations have increasingly turned to multi-layered encrypted messaging services specifically to evade monitoring by intelligence agencies.

The Virtual SIM Problem

Alongside app-layer evasion, foreign-issued virtual SIM cards remain a persistent headache for investigators. The most cited example remains the 2019 Pulwama attack investigation, in which agencies reportedly traced more than 40 virtual SIM cards to the Jaish-e-Mohammed suicide bomber and his network numbers that could be provisioned and abandoned without ever touching an Indian telecom's KYC system. That case became something of a template for how virtual and foreign-registered numbers can be used to build communication chains that are extremely difficult to map after the fact, since there is no physical SIM, no retail purchase record, and often no domestic carrier data trail at all.

More recent J&K cases echo the same pattern in a different form. Police investigating a cross-border radicalisation network noted that intelligence agencies now suspect unauthorised SIM card distribution is being used by terrorists to communicate with handlers across the border, part of a broader push to choke off the logistical and communication backbone that keeps sleeper modules alive even when direct physical contact with a local handler is minimal or non-existent.

How Agencies Are Responding

To their credit, security agencies aren't standing still. Officials say cyber-surveillance frameworks are actively being redesigned to map and intercept these "off-grid" communication channels, a phrase that itself signals how far outside traditional monitoring territory this recruitment method has moved. Agencies say they continue to adapt their cyber-surveillance frameworks specifically to map and intercept these off-grid communication channels. That has included moving to restrict access to specific APKs, tightening scrutiny of virtual number providers, and, as seen in recent CIK (Counter Intelligence Kashmir) operations, proactively disrupting online propaganda networks before recruitment pitches can mature into operational plots. One recent CIK operation, for instance, intercepted attempts to recruit two teenage boys who were allegedly being fed terror content in the direction of a Pakistan-based handler, underlining how young the target pool for these campaigns has become.

Conclusion

What this episode really illustrates isn't a single clever trick but a structural truth about counter-terror surveillance: it is inherently reactive. Every time agencies build competence around a platform, handlers find a low-attention, high-friction-to-monitor alternative: first fringe messaging apps, then Tor-routed clients, and now the sprawling, largely unregulated back-end of adult content platforms, which few people would ever think to associate with national security. It's a reminder that the fight against radicalisation online is no longer confined to obviously "extremist" corners of the internet;  it can hide in plain sight, inside the most ordinary-looking corners of the web.

Sources

1. New J-K terror tactic: Pornography apps, Tor network used for secret messaging — The Tribune
2. New J&K terror tactic: Handlers turn to porn sites, encrypted apps to contact recruits — Deccan Herald
3. Terrorists using porn website, encrypted apps for chats with recruits — Organiser
4. New J&K Terror Tactic: Pornography Apps, Tor Network Used For Secret Messaging — Kashmir Dot Com
5. From WhatsApp to Porn Sites: Terror Groups Adopt New Digital Tactic in J&K — Jammu Kashmir Now
6. Jammu teenager's arrest exposes cross-border radicalisation network — The Tribune
7. After OGW network, J&K cops target communication channel of terrorists — The Tribune
8. CIK busts online radical network, foils recruitment of two minors — The Tribune

‍

‍Introduction

Picture every paper trade document, such as bills of lading, certificates of origin, letters of credit, and packing lists, stacked one on top of another. By one industry estimate, the roughly four billion such documents in circulation each year would form a tower over 500 kilometres high, well past the edge of space. This absurd image reflects a simple truth, global trade has relied on paper for centuries, making transactions slow, expensive, and vulnerable to loss, forgery, and disputes.

Today, however, we complete many activities that once depended on paper through digital platforms. We open bank accounts through mobile applications, sign contracts electronically, file taxes online, and access government services through websites, all without handling a single physical document. Global trade is now undergoing a similar transformation. Yet, as trade moves online, the challenge is no longer managing stacks of paper, but protecting digital trade from cyber threats. The success of this transition will therefore depend as much on robust cybersecurity as on the adoption of digital technologies.

From Paper Trails to Platforms

For decades, an Indian exporter clearing a container needed physical stamps from customs, port authorities, banks, and multiple regulatory agencies, each on its own timeline. That has been changing under India's National Trade Facilitation Action Plan, now in its third iteration (NTFAP 3.0, 2024–27), which set out to close the remaining gaps in paperless trading systems. The shift shows up in international benchmarks: India's score on the UN's Global Survey on Digital and Sustainable Trade Facilitation has climbed sharply, with the institutional-cooperation component alone improving from under 67% to nearly 89% in recent rounds. A 2026 policy brief jointly released by ICRIER, RIS, and the Centre for WTO Studies concludes that India has achieved full implementation of domestic paperless trade measures, a rare distinction globally even as cross-border digitalisation continues to deepen.

The Building Blocks: ICEGATE to BharatTradeNet

This transformation rests on a stack of interlocking platforms. ICEGATE, the customs electronic data-interchange gateway, lets traders file declarations digitally rather than in person. SWIFT, the Single Window Interface for Facilitating Trade, connects multiple regulatory agencies so a trader deals with one portal instead of dozens. e-SANCHIT digitises supporting documents for customs clearance, cutting paperwork once attached to every consignment. Faceless assessment, rolled out under the CBIC's "Turant Customs" push, separates the assessing officer from the physical location of the goods, reducing scope for delay and discretion. The newest addition, BharatTradeNet, announced in the Union Budget 2025-26, is unified digital public infrastructure linking DGFT, GSTN, banks, shipping lines, and exporters on one platform for trade documentation and financing built to complement the Unified Logistics Interface Platform and align with international conventions.

None of this works without a legal backbone. India's proposed Trade Facilitation Bill aims to give electronic trade documents the same legal standing as paper ones, closing an interoperability gap that has long complicated cross-border recognition of digital records. Recent trade agreements have also begun embedding firmer commitments on paperless trade, a sign that digitalisation is no longer a back-office IT project but a live item in trade diplomacy.

What's at Stake Economically

The economic case is straightforward: paper costs money and time. Digitised customs and documentation shrink dwell times at ports, cut transaction costs, and reduce the discretion-driven delays that disproportionately hurt smaller firms. That matters for India's MSMEs, whose export contribution has grown from roughly ₹3.95 lakh crore to ₹12.39 lakh crore in recent years, aided by platforms such as the Government e-Marketplace and ONDC, which together have onboarded well over a million sellers. Electronics exports touched a record $47 billion in 2025, helped along by production-linked incentives and smoother compliance. With India's total merchandise exports crossing $714 billion in the first ten months of FY 2025-26, the efficiency gains from digitalisation compound across an ever-larger base and help Indian firms plug into global value chains that increasingly expect real-time, verifiable documentation rather than faxed certificates.

India's Regional Moment

Beyond its own backyard, India has regional aspirations. Following deliberations at the Asia-Pacific Trade Facilitation Forum and Paperless Trade Week 2026 in Bangkok last May, international experts were of the opinion that most of the necessary digital and regulatory infrastructure for India to join the UN Framework Agreement on Facilitation of Cross-Border Paperless Trade in Asia and the Pacific (CPTA – a treaty-based and intended to make paperless trade globally, not just internationally, interoperable) had been laid in place. Joining CPTA will also allow India to have a say on digital trade frameworks in the region and thus be a game-changer in integrating SAARC, ASEAN and global supply chains together while reducing costs of trade.

The Cybersecurity Imperative

The catch is that every portal, system and API that takes the place of a paper stamp has the potential to become an attack vector. The increase in overall ransomware activity reached more than 50% worldwide in 2025, and supply-chain attacks almost doubled. These types of attacks hit manufacturing, now a key part of India's export basket, hardest of all industrial ransomware attacks.

The notorious NotPetya attack in 2017, which effectively brought Maersk's worldwide shipping operations to a halt and shut down container movement at Mumbai's Jawaharlal Nehru Port, serves as a painful reminder that the compromise of even a single system can bring physical cargo movement within a network to a standstill.

For a trade ecosystem running on digital trust, the nature of risks include: ransomware that immobilizes ports and customs systems, supply-chain attacks that leverage a single trusted service provider to get access to dozens of downstream clients, data theft revealing shipment and financial data, impostor fraud to trick people into assuming the identity of a banks or exporter, modification of digital bills of lading, certificates of origin or other essential trade documents. When an original physical document is misplaced, it has no effect on anyone but its keeper. A corrupted digital file, on the other hand, can be stealthily changed and propagate across every system it touches instantly.

Building Trust by Design

It is a prerequisite to digital commerce to have these systems so they can even be trusted. This means a zero-trust architecture where all users and devices are authenticated rather than just assumed to be safe once you cross an organisational boundary; transport-level encryption; digital signatures & PKI for crypto-validating shipping documents; identity & access controls ensuring access to shipment data is limited to authorised persons; and anomaly detection to alert on intrusions before the problems can snowball. India's legal & policy framework for cybersecurity is indeed evolving, with the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (and its rules finalised Jan 2025) obligating data fiduciaries & stipulating breaches must be reported within 6 hours to CERT-In; the National Cyber Security Reference Framework provides a foundational blueprint for digital public infrastructure, all under the stewardship of the National Critical Information Infrastructure Protection Centre, which monitors systems vital for the functioning of commerce.

Conclusion

India's digitised trade infrastructure from ICEGATE and SWIFT to e-SANCHIT, BharatTradeNet, and faceless customs has effectively brought it into the running for the title of regional digital trade leader. However, the success of this transformation will ultimately be measured not by the number of digital platforms it deploys, but by the trust, security, and resilience of the ecosystem that supports them. As trade becomes increasingly digital, robust cybersecurity will remain the foundation for protecting commercial data, maintaining confidence among trading partners, and ensuring that India's digital trade ambitions translate into sustainable economic growth.

Sources

1. Cyble — Ransomware Attacks and Supply Chain Threats in 2025
2. Chambers and Partners — Cybersecurity 2026: India
3. Drishti IAS — Key Cyberthreats India is Facing and Key Measures India has Adopted to Strengthen Cybersecurity
4. Protium — MSME Export Contribution Has Grown from ₹3.95 Lakh Crore to ₹12.39 Lakh Crore
5. IBEF — India's E-commerce Boom: Growth, Trends & Future Prospects
6. News on Air — India Achieves Record Electronics Exports of $47 Billion in 2025

‍

Introduction 

Betting has long been associated with sporting activities and has found a growing presence in online gaming and esports globally. As the esports industry continues to expand, Statista has projected that it will reach a market value of $5.9 billion by 2029. As such, associated markets have also seen significant growth. In 2024, this segment accounted for an estimated $2.5 billion globally. While such engagement avenues are popular among international audiences, they also bring attention to concerns around regulation, integrity, and user protection. As esports builds its credibility and reach, especially among younger demographics, these aspects become increasingly important to address in policy and practice.

What Does Esports Betting Involve? 

Much like traditional sports, esports engagement in some regions includes the practice of wagering on teams, players, or match outcomes. But it is inherently more complex. The accurate valuation of odds in online gaming and esports can be complicated by frequently updated game titles, changing teams, and shifting updates to game mechanics (called metas- most effective strategies). Bets can be placed using real money, virtual items like skins (digital avatars), or increasingly, cryptocurrency. 

Esports and Wagering: Emerging Issues and Implications

1. Legal Grey Areas:  While countries like South Korea and some USA states have dedicated regulations for esports betting and licensed bookmaking, most do not. This creates legal grey areas for betting service providers to access unregulated markets, increasing the risk of fraud, money laundering, and exploitation of bettors in those regions.  
2. The Skill v/s Chance Dilemma:  Most gambling laws across the world regulate betting based on the distinction between ‘games of skill’ and ‘games of chance’.  Betting on the latter is typically illegal, since winning depends on chance. But the definitions of ‘skill’ and ‘chance’ may vary by jurisdiction. Also, esports betting often blurs into gambling.  Outcomes may depend on player skill, but in-game economies like skin betting and unpredictable gameplay introduce elements of chance, complicating regulation and making enforcement difficult.
3. Underage Gambling and Addiction Risks: Players are often minors and are exposed to the gambling ecosystem due to gamified betting through reward systems like loot boxes. These often mimic the mechanics of betting, normalising gambling behaviours among young users before they fully understand the risks. This can lead to the development of addictive behaviours. 
4. Match-Fixing and Loss of Integrity: Esports are particularly susceptible to match-fixing because of weak regulation, financial pressures, and the anonymity of online betting. Instances like the Dota 2 Southeast Asia Scandals (2023) and Valorant match-fixing in North America (2021) can jeopardise audience trust and sponsorships. This affects the trustworthiness of minor tournaments, where talent is discovered.
5. Cybersecurity and Data Risks:  Esports betting apps collect sensitive user data, making them an attractive target for cybercrime. Bettors are susceptible to identity theft, financial fraud, and data breaches, especially on unlicensed platforms. 

Way Forward

To strengthen trust, ensure user safety, and protect privacy within the esports ecosystem, responsible management of betting practices can be achieved through targeted interventions focused on:

1. National-Level Regulations: Countries like India have a large online gaming and esports market. It will need to create a regulatory authority along the lines of the UK’s Gambling Commission and update its gambling laws to protect consumers.   
2. Protection of Minors: Setting guardrails such as age verification, responsible advertising, anti-fraud mechanisms, self-exclusion tools, and spending caps can help to keep a check on gambling by minors.
3. Harmonizing Global Standards:  Since esports is inherently global, aligning core regulatory principles across jurisdictions (such as through multi-country agreements or voluntary industry codes of conduct) can help create consistency while avoiding overregulation. 
4. Co-Regulation: Governments, esports organisers, betting platforms, and player associations should work closely to design effective, well-informed policies. This can help uphold the interests of all stakeholders in the industry.

Conclusion

Betting in esports is inevitable. But the industry faces a double dilemma- overregulating on the one hand, or letting gambling go unchecked, on the other. Both can be detrimental to its growth. This is why there is a need for industry actors like policymakers, platforms and organisers to work together to harmonise legal inconsistencies, protect vulnerable users and invest in forming data security. Forming industry-wide ethics boards, promoting regional regulatory dialogue, and instating transparency measures for betting operators can be a step in this direction to ensure that esports evolves into a mature, trusted global industry.

Sources 

• https://www.statista.com/outlook/amo/esports/esports-betting/worldwide 
• https://www.skrill.com/en/skrill-news/gaming/how-does-esports-betting-work/ 
• https://www.si.com/esports/betting/biggest-challenges-esports-betting ‍
• https://www.topesportsbettingsites.com/country/india/